Archives of Acoustics, 41, 2, pp. 221–232, 2016

Noise Annoyance Caused by Amplitude Modulated Sounds Resembling the Main Characteristics of Temporal Wind Turbine Noise

Honorata Zofia HAFKE-DYS
Adam Mickiewicz University

Adam Mickiewicz University

Adam Mickiewicz University

Adam Mickiewicz University

Adam Mickiewicz University

Annoyance ratings for artificially created noises, resembling the main characteristics of temporal wind turbine noise, were studied by means of a listening experiment involving 21 participants with normal hearing. Three types of stimuli were examined: broadband noise (−4 dB/octave), noise generated by moving cars, and narrowband noise. All stimuli had the sound level fluctuations typical for wind turbine noise. The magnitude of the sound level fluctuations was measured in a quantitative way, by using the characteristics of amplitude modulated sound: modulation rate and modulation depth. Our aim was to examine how the modulation rate and the modulation depth influence the noise annoyance assessment of broadband and narrowband amplitude modulated noises. Three different modulation rates, 1, 2 and 4 Hz, and sound level fluctuations (a measure of the modulation depth), 3, 6, 9 dB, were applied to each type of stimuli (with exception of noise generated by the moving cars) and investigated. The participants in the listening experiment were presented with sound stimuli in laboratory conditions and asked to rate their annoyance on a numerical scale. The results have shown a significant difference between the investigated conditions. The effect was particularly strong between the annoyance judgments of different types of noise (narrow and broadband), and modulated versus unmodulated noises. Temporal fluctuations occurring in wind turbine noise are very pertinent to the perception of annoyance and could be responsible for its being a relatively annoying noise source. The obtained results were discussed and compared to the typical modulation rates and level changes that occur in recordings of real wind turbine noise.
Keywords: wind turbines amplitude modulation; noise annoyance.
Full Text: PDF
Copyright © Polish Academy of Sciences & Institute of Fundamental Technological Research (IPPT PAN).


ANSI Specifications for Audiometers, American National Standards Institute, New York, ANSI S3, 1996; 6-1996.

Bakker R., Pedersen E., van den Berg G., Stewart R., Lok W., Bouma J. (2012), Impact of wind turbine sound on annoyance, self-reported sleep disturbance and psychological distress, Sci. Total. Environ., 425, 42–51.

Berglund B., Berglund U., Lindvall T. (1976), Scaling loudness, noisiness, and annoyance of community noises, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 60, 1119–1126.

Berglund B. (1991), Quality assurance in environmental psychophysics, [in:] Ratio scaling of psychological magnitudes – in honor of the memory of S.S. Stevens, Bolanowski S., Gescheider G. [Eds.], Hillsdale, New Jersey, L. Erlbaum Associates.

Bockstael A., Dekoninck L., Can A., Oldoni D., De Coensel B., Botteldooren D. (2012), Reduction of wind turbine noise annoyance: an operational approach, Acta Acust. Acust., 98, 392–401.

Bolin K., Bluhm G., Eriksson G., Nilsson M. (2011), Infrasound and low frequency noise from wind turbines: exposure and health effects, Environ. Res. Lett., 6, 035103.

Bolin K. (2009), Prediction method for wind-induced vegetation noise, Acta Acust. Acust., 95, 607–19.

Bolin K., Nilsson M., Shafiquzzaman K. (2010), The potential of natural sounds to mask wind turbine noise, Acta Acust. Acust., 96, 131–7.

Botteldooren D., Verkeyn A. (2002), Fuzzy models for accumulation of reported community noise annoyance from combined sources, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 112, 1496–508.

Botteldooren D., Lavandier C., Preis A., Dubois D., Aspuru I., Guastavino C., Brown L., Nillson M., Andringa T.C. (2011), Understanding urban and natural soundscapes, Proceedings of Forum Acusticum 2011, Aalborg, Denmark.

Chang E., Merzenich M. (2003), Environmental noise retards auditory cortical development, Science, 300, 498–502.

De Coensel B., Botteldooren D., De Muer T., Berglund B., Nilsson M., Lercher P.A. (2009), Model for the perception of environmental sound based on notice-events, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 126, 656–65.

Diaz C., Pedrero A. (2005), The reverberation time of furnished rooms in dwellings, Appl. Acoust., 66, 945–56.

Dittrich K., Oberfeld D. (2009), A comparison of the temporal weighting of annoyance and loudness, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 126, 3168–3178.

Fastl H., Zwicker E. (2007), Psychoacoustics: Facts and Models, Berlin, Springer Verlag.

Fégeant O. (1999), Wind-induced vegetation noise. Part 1: a prediction model, Acta Acust. Acust., 85, 228–40.

F´egeant O. (2002), Masking of wind turbine noise: Influence of wind turbulence on ambient noise fluctuations, Technical report 12, Sweden: Department of Civil and Architectural Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology.

Fields J.M., De Jong R.G., Flindell I.H., Job R.F.S., Kurra S., Lercher P., Vallet M., Yano T., Guski R., Felscher-Suhr U., Schumer R. (2001), Standardized general-purpose noise reaction questions for community noise surveys: Research and a recommendation, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 242, 4, 641–679.

Fritz J., Elhilali M., David S., Shamma S. (2007), Auditory attention – focusing the searchlight on sound, Curr. Opin. Neurobiol., 17, 437–55.

Hellman R.P. (1982), Loudness, annoyance, and noisiness produced by single-tone-noise complexes, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 72, 62–73.

Hubbard H., Shepherd K. (1991), Aeroacoustics of large wind turbines, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 89, 2495–508.

ISO 8253-1:1989. Acoustics – audiometric test methods – part 1: basic pure tone air and bone conduction threshold audiometry. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organisation for Standardisation, 1989.

ISO 9613-1:1996. Acoustics – attenuation of sound during propagation outdoors – part 1. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organisation for Standardisation, 1996.

ISO 9613-2:1996. Acoustics – attenuation of sound during propagation outdoors – part 2. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organisation for Standardisation, 1996.

ISO 15666:2003(E). Acoustics – assessment of noise annoyance by means of social and socio-acoustical surveys, Geneva, Switzerland, ISO/TS, 2003.

ISO 18233:2006. Acoustics – application of new measurement methods in building and room acoustics. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organisation for Standardisation, 2006.

ISO 3382-1:2009. Acoustics – measurement of room acoustic parameters – part 1: performance spaces. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organisation for Standardisation, 2009.

Jacobsen J. (2005), Infrasound emission from Wind Turbines, Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control, 24, 3, 145–155.

Janssen S., Vos H., Eisses A., Pedersen E.A. (2011), Comparison between exposure-response relationships for wind turbine annoyance and annoyance due to other noise sources, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 130, 3746–53.

Jonasson H. (2007), Acoustical source modeling of road vehicles, Acta Acust. Acust., 93, 173–84.

Krippendorff K. (1980), Content Analysis, an Introduction to Its Methodology, Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications.

Lee S., Kim K., Choi W., Lee S. (2011), Annoyance caused by amplitude modulation of wind turbine noise, Noise Control Eng., 59, 38–46.

Legarth S.V. (2007), Auralization and assessment of annoyance from wind turbines, Proc. 2nd Int. Meeeting on Wind Turbine Noise, Lyon.

Lercher P. (1995), Distinguishing effects modifiers of psychological morbidity associated with traffic noise exposure, Epidemiology, S28, P085.

Li H., Chau C., Tang S. (2010), Can surrounding greenery reduce noise annoyance at home?, Sci. Total Environ., 408, 4376–84.

Miedema H.M.E., Oudshoorn C.G.M. (2001), Annoyance from Transportation Noise: Relationships with Exposure Metrics DNL and DENL and Their Confidence Intervals, Environmental Health Perspectives, 109, 4, 409–416.

Miedema H., Vos H. (2003), Noise sensitivity and reactions to noise and other environmental conditions, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 113, 1492–504.

Miedema H.M.E., Vos H. (2004), Noise Annoyance from Stationary sources: relationships with Exposure Metric day-evening-night level (DENL) and Their Confidence Intervals, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 116, 1, 334–343.

Moler H., Pedersen C. (2011), Low-frequency noise from large wind turbines, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 129, 3727–44.

Moorhouse A., Hayes M., von H¨unerbein S., Piper B., Adams M. (2007), Research into aerodynamic modulation of wind turbine noise: final report, Technical Report. UK, Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.

Ohrström E., Barregård L., Andersson E., Skånberg A., Svensson H., Angerheim P. (2007), Annoyance due to single and combined sound exposure from railway and road traffic, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 122, 2642–52.

Palmer W.A. (2009), New explanation for wind turbine whoosh – wind shear, Proceedings of Third International Meeting on Wind Turbine Noise, Aalborg, Denmark; 2009.

Pedersen E., Larsman P. (2008) The impact of visual factors on noise annoyance among people living in the vicinity of wind turbines, J. Environ. Psychol., 28, 379–89.

Pedersen E., Persson-Waye K. (2004), Perception and annoyance due to wind turbine noise – a dose-response relationship, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 116, 3460–70.

Pedersen E., Persson-Waye K. (2007), Wind turbine noise, annoyance and self-reported health and well-being in different living environments, Occup. Environ. Med., 64, 480–6.

Pedersen E., van den Berg F., Bakker R., Bouma J. (2009), Response to noise from modern wind farms in The Netherlands, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 126, 634–43.

Pedersen E., van den Berg F., Bakker R., Bouma J. (2010), Can road traffic mask sound from wind turbines? Response to wind turbine sound at different levels of road traffic sound, Energy Policy 38, 2520–7.

PersonWaye K., ¨Ohstr¨om E. (2002), Psychoacoustic characters of relevance for annoyance of wind turbine noise, J. Sound. Vib., 250, 1, 65–73.

Preis A., Kaczmarek T., Wojciechowska H., Zera J., Fields J.M. (2003), Polish version of the standardized noise reaction questions for the community noise surveys, Int. J. Occup. Med. Environ. Health., 16, 2, 155-159.

Quirt J. (1983), Sound transmission through windows II. Double and triple glazing, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 74, 534–42

R Core Team (2015), R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. URL

Salt A., Hullar T. (2010), Responses of the ear to low frequency sounds, infrasound and wind turbines, Hear. Res., 268, 12–21.

Schutte M., Marks A., Wenning E., Griefahn B. (2007), The development of the noise sensitivity questionnaire, Noise Health, 9, 15–24.

Tachibana H. (2014), Synthetic research of wind turbine noise in Japan, Forum Acusticum, 7–12 September 2014 Kraków, Poland.

Van den Berg G. (2004), Effects of the wind profile at night on wind turbine sound, J. Sound Vib., 277, 955–70.

Van den Berg G.P. (2005), The beat is getting stronger:the effect of atmospheric stability on low frequency modulated sound of wind turbines, Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Noise Control, 24, 1.

Van den Berg F. (2009), Why is turbine noise noiser than other noise?, Proc. Euronoise, Edinburgh. 58. Van Gerven P., Vos H., Boxtel M., Janssen S., Miedema H. (2009), Annoyance from environmental noise across the lifespan, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 126, 187–94.

Van Renterghem T., Bockstael A., De Weirt V., Botteldooren D. (2013), Annoyance, detection and recognition of wind turbine noise, Science of the Total Environment, 456–457, 333–345.

Van Renterghem T., Botteldooren D. (2012), Focused study on the quiet side effect at dwellings highly exposed by road traffic noise, Int. J. Environ. Res. PublicHealth, 9, 4292–310.

Viollon S., Lavandier C., Drake C. (2002), Influence of visual setting on sound ratings in an urban environment, Appl. Acoust., 63, 493–511.

Warren C., Lumsden C., O’Dowd S., Birnie R. (2010), Green on green: public perceptions of wind power in Scotland and Ireland, J. Environ. Plann Manag., 48, 853–75.

Weinstein N. (1978), Individual differences in reactions to noise: a longitudinal study in a college dormitory, J. Appl. Psychol., 63, 458–66.

Yokoyama S., Sakamoto S., Tachibana H. (2013), Study on the amplitude modulation of wind turbine noise: part 2 – Auditory experiments, Internoise 2013, Innsbruck.

DOI: 10.1515/aoa-2016-0022